Bettering Me

Exercise Snacking vs One Long Workout: What an 8-Week Squat Trial Found

Woman doing bodyweight squats at home in a living room
Photo by MART PRODUCTION on Pexels

Written by

–

Drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by Kurt Greiner. How we use AI.

Can you build strength in short bursts squeezed into your day instead of one long gym session? A new randomized controlled trial tested the idea with 45 young men and found that three short squat bouts a day and one continuous session produced comparable gains over 8 weeks. The snacking group also enjoyed training more. The study was small, though, and it looked at one lift in one narrow group.[1]

What the researchers did

The trial, published in the October 2026 issue of the Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness, enrolled 45 recreationally trained male students aged 18 to 25 who had at least 6 months of training experience. They were randomized into three groups: fragmented resistance training, traditional resistance training, or a time-matched control group.[1]

Fragmented resistance training is a form of exercise snacking: three short bouts a day, each one set of 20 squats. The traditional group did one continuous session of 3 sets of 20 squats. Total volume was matched. Both groups trained three times a week for 8 weeks on a Smith machine, with the load rising from 40% to 55% of their one-repetition maximum (the heaviest weight you can lift once).[1]

The team measured squat 1RM, isometric squat force (pushing against an immovable load), muscular endurance (repetitions at 40% of current 1RM) and exercise enjoyment on a standard questionnaire.[1]

What they found

Both training groups beat the control group on every strength measure. Changes versus control, with 95% confidence intervals:[1]

  • Squat 1RM: fragmented +20.59 kg (8.69 to 32.49); traditional +28.93 kg (17.05 to 40.82).[1]
  • Isometric squat force: fragmented +27.89 kgf (12.15 to 43.64); traditional +35.24 kgf (19.48 to 51.00).[1]
  • Muscular endurance: fragmented +9.97 repetitions (1.68 to 18.27); traditional +14.11 repetitions (5.84 to 22.38).[1]

The difference between the fragmented and traditional groups was not statistically significant on any of the three measures (p = 0.164, 0.353 and 0.320). The fragmented group did report significantly higher enjoyment (p = 0.034).[1]

What this study does not show

  • “No significant difference” is not the same as “identical.” The traditional group’s average gains were numerically larger on every measure. With only 45 people split across three groups, the trial may have been too small to detect a real gap.
  • Everyone was a young, recreationally trained man. The results may not carry over to women, older adults or beginners.[1]
  • The exercise was one lift, the squat, with matched volume and fairly light loads. It does not tell you how snacking compares for other lifts, heavier training or muscle size.
  • Eight weeks is short. The authors say longer research on whether people actually stick with it is needed.[1]

What to do with this

  • If a full session keeps getting skipped, splitting the same work into a few short bouts is a reasonable thing to try. This trial suggests the strength gains may not suffer much, at least for squats in the short term.
  • Enjoyment matters because the best plan is the one you keep doing. That is a hypothesis here, not something this trial measured.
  • Keep the effort real: the load in the trial was progressive and the volume matched the long session. Three casual sets do not equal three planned bouts.
  • If you have joint problems, a heart condition or you are new to lifting, check with your clinician or a qualified coach before adding loaded squats.

References

[1] Zhai R, Yang K, Dai H, Wang Y, Jiang Y, Wu X, Wang L. Fragmented versus traditional resistance training: a randomized controlled trial on muscular strength, endurance, and enjoyment in recreationally trained young adults. Journal of Exercise Science & Fitness, 2026;24:200521. Trial registration ChiCTR2500115052. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesf.2026.200521. Finding as used: in 45 recreationally trained male students, 8 weeks of fragmented (3 daily bouts of 1×20 squats) and traditional (3×20 squats in one session) training both beat control on squat 1RM, isometric force and muscular endurance, with no significant difference between the two training groups; fragmented training was rated more enjoyable (p = 0.034). ↑︎ a b c d e f g h i j k

Kurt Greiner
Kurt Greiner

Kurt is a digital strategist and IT professional blending emerging technology with practical application, exploring how individuals can leverage modern tools to navigate the second half of life with purpose.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This website provides wellness information for educational purposes only. It is not medical advice. Consult a healthcare professional before making any health-related decisions or changes.

Bettering Me Wellness 40+ logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.